The 5 Best Butter Dishes with Lids (Review)

4.6/5 - (25 votes)

Some hot toast spread with some fresh butter along with some fresh juice or some coffee sounds like a perfect breakfast for your day but most of us are in such a rush in the morning that we got to settle for refrigerated market available butter spread on some toast eaten in the car or while running off to the car with a side of frustration.

Best Butter Dishes with Lid

Most of the people don’t care about what butter they are having on a daily basis or how they are having their breakfast but why not enjoy all the little things in our life in our day to day routines as much as we can?

Let’s just fix the cold, hard butter and having to deal with it everyday just by buying a butter dish. A butter dish keeps the butter from getting hard and keeps the butter in a spreadable, room temperature.

Does a Butter Dish Keep Butter Soft?

The response to this inquiry spins around two parts of the butter dish: How impenetrable the lid is and how much butter you need to put within the dish. Recollect that butter is a dairy item. In the event that it interacts with air, a great deal of the supplements of the butter will be taken out and it won’t be as delicate as it was in its unique bundle.

A butter dish will keep butter delicate, however all together for the dish to keep the butter delicate, the lid must have the option to keep the butter from interacting with however much air as could be expected. Some butter dishes contain lids that are really hermetically sealed, implying that they can keep any air outside of the dish while the butter inside stays delicate for as far as might be feasible.

Additionally, remember that the less butter you leave in a dish, the more air it can interact with. This air will be within the dish itself, and if the lid isn’t hermetically sealed, air from outside of the dish will enter it, evaporating whatever butter is inside. In this way, try to put as much butter as possible in a dish in the event that you intend to utilize said dish to store butter.

Best Butter Dishes with Lids

There are so many Butter Dishes available in the market and you never know which is the right one to buy. To help you make the right choice for adding little joy to your life, we reviewed a plethora of butter dishes and for you, we reviewed what we found to be The 5 Best Butter Dishes.

1. OXO Good Grips Butter Dish: Best Budget Pick

OXO Good Grips Butter Dish,White/Clear,OXO Butter Dish

$11.95  in stock
7 new from $11.95
5 used from $10.99
Free shipping
as of March 19, 2023 1:50 am


  • Material: BPA free plastic
  • Dimensions: 7.9 x 2.6 x 2 inches
  • Weight: 4.9 ounces
  • Model number: 11122500
  • Amazon rating: 4.7/5

With a size of 7.9 x 2.6 x 2 inches, it is a roomy butter dish that can oblige both short and long butter sticks. It has been totally structured with plugs on either side that blocks the butter from sneaking off when being moved.

All the more curiously, butter dish that has been worked from without BPA plastic material, which makes it exceptionally solid for long haul execution. Since it is minus BPA, the butter dish is okay for keeping the butter. The dish has an unmistakable lid that lays on it without sliding off. It is a simple to eliminate and never gets earth since it doesn’t interact with the butter. The perfectly clear completion of the lid carries quality class to the morning meal table.

A helpful tablespoon has been consolidated in the dish for simple estimations. The dish likewise has estimation markings as an afterthought for simple cutting. For just $9.99; it’s the best you can get for just a few bucks. 10 on 10 the top budget pick.

The dishwasher safe butter dish is basic to clean for long haul use. The main eminent deficiency with this butter dish is that it won’t hold cheddar well. However, this is just a disadvantage for those that incline toward something flexible they can likewise use for cheese.


  • Includes stoppers to keep butter in place.
  • Accommodates short and long butter sticks.
  • Tablespoon Measurement markers.
  • OXO better guarantee.
  • Have crystal clear lid.
  • Dishwasher safe.


  • Does not work well for cheese.

2. The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain

Butter Bell - The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain, French Ceramic Butter Dish, Antique Collection, Azure Blue

$20.00  in stock

1 used from $20.00
Free shipping
as of March 19, 2023 1:50 am


  • Material: Ceramic
  • Dimensions: 4.00 x 4.00 x 4.00 inches
  • Weight: 1 pound
  • Model number: BB-AQAZ
  • Amazon rating: 4.5/5

The L.Tremain butter ringer vessel is the better than ever form of the first French butter container. Its structure includes a ringer formed lead and a container as the base. The container is produced using profoundly tough new bone china earth that guarantees that the butter inside the vessel stays new and delicate for in any event 30 days.

The butter is kept inside the altered chime formed lid and the water kept in the base of the container guarantees the flavour and newness of it by making the butter guardian impenetrable. The water must be eliminated in 2-3 days to keep up the new kind of the butter.

The container is advantageously estimated and can save to one stick of butter. The first ringer butter container can be a pleasant expansion to your kitchen style. It can include a hint of natural fascinate to your kitchen with its plan. It comes in nine unique shades of shading. The strong new bone china of the vessel makes it scratch safe. All things considered; the first chime butter container is a decent kitchen contraption that will improve your kitchen stylistic layout.


  • Can keep butter fresh and soft for 30 days.
  • Comes in different colours and shaded.
  • Is durable and dishwasher safe.
  • Free of cadmium and lead.
  • Can offer a rustic charm to your kitchen décor.
  • Can also be used to serve Cheese.


  • The butter may fall into the water in some cases.
  • You’ll have to ensure the container is away from sunlight and heat.

3. Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish

Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish, 6-1/2-Inch by 2-3/4-Inch

$16.80  in stock
3 new from $15.99
Free shipping
as of March 19, 2023 1:50 am


  • Material: Glass
  • Dimensions: 6.69 x 4.13 x 2.76 inches
  • Weight: 1.35 pounds
  • Model number: 41171
  • Amazon rating: 4.8/5

Luminarc cow butter dish is made of exceptionally solid thick glass. The estimation of one butter dish is 6-1/2 by 2-3/4-inch. It is 100% sterile and is wash safe. The glass of the dish is weighty, thick and completely tempered, that is the glass won’t break or harm at various temperatures. The lid can have more than one use; it tends to be loaded up with squashed ice and be held under the base of the dish to keep the butter inside cool and new over a holiday supper or expanded smorgasbord dinner. It is anything but difficult to lift the lead due to the itemized dairy animals plan on it.

The butter dish has an adequate sufficient space to oblige two sticks of butter or 8 ounces of European style butter. On the off chance that you are searching for a simple to utilize butter dish with adequate capacity limit then you can think about buying this one. This dish consolidates an easy-going structure that is ideal for ever day use. A cow is emblazoned on the internal surface to give a more exquisite intrigue. This dish doesn’t highlight any flooding wreck and it is worked to last. The dish estimates 6.5 inches by 2.75 inches. It can easily oblige a 1-pound square of butter. This dish has a straightforward acrylic development. It has a perfectly clear completion that carries class to the morning meal table. It is a multi-useful dish that can be utilized for butter and cheddar sticks. The lid fuses a handle at the top to give better hold. It is dishwasher ok for simple cleaning and upkeep.


  • Is wash resistant, and hygienic.
  • Is large enough to store a good amount of butter.
  • The Lid has many uses.
  • Is well made, thick and durable.
  • Transparent glass makes it easy to check how much butter is left.


  • Glass body requires you to handle the butter dish very carefully at all times.
  • The lid does not have any knob; making lifting the lid a bit difficult.

4. Norpro Porcelain Butter Dish with Lid

Norpro Porcelain Butter Dish with Lid

$16.98  in stock
6 new from $8.38
Free shipping
as of March 19, 2023 1:50 am


  • Material: Porcelain
  • Dimensions: 3.00 x 3.75 x 7.75 inches
  • Weight: 1.28 pounds
  • Model number: 8370
  • Amazon rating: 4.7/5

Because of the elegant design, this is a rich butter dish that will facilitate both current and customary kitchen styles. Aside from this, it has a huge size of 7.5 x 3.75 x 3 inches and, subsequently can oblige in excess of a butter stick. It has been made from white porcelain material, which makes it ideal for keeping the butter new and cool. All the more curiously, the assembled likewise guarantees long haul administration in addition to includes an extraordinary look in your kitchen counter.

The top handle lid takes into account simple holding to effectively open and spread the dish. This makes it an easy to use dish that will impeccably suit your kitchen. Being a top-rack dishwasher safe butter dish, it is rudimentary to clean and keep up. The inside of the dish has been totally furrowed to impede the butter from sliding and, in this manner, less jumble.

Since it is produced using porcelain, the lid isn’t straightforward however this is not really a critical downside as it doesn’t influence its handiness.


  • Allows for easy gripping.
  • Top-rack dishwasher safe.
  • Perfectly coordinates any kitchen décor
  • Keeps butter fresh and cool


  • The lid isn’t transparent which does nor really count as a con.

5. Norpro Stainless Steel Double Covered Butter Dish

Norpro Stainless Steel Double Covered Butter Dish

$13.94  in stock
9 new from $13.94
Free shipping
as of March 19, 2023 1:50 am


  • Material: Stainless Steel
  • Dimensions: 2.50 x 4.00 x 7.50 inches
  • Weight: 3.2 ounces
  • Model number: 282
  • Amazon rating: 4.6/5

This is an alluring, straightforward, and exquisite butter dish that adds both class and polish to your morning meal table. It has a size of 7.5 x 4 x 2.5 inches and, in this manner, a flexible dish that suits longer and shorter butter sticks. The dish fits a square of cream cheddar or two sticks of butter.

Second, to this, the butter dish is worked from the highest calibre of hardened steel material, which makes it appealing and sturdy. It is additionally rust and erosion safe, which suits it for the kitchen counter. The handheld lid gives a safe hold to a rudimentary opening and shutting of the dish. The lid is sufficiently enormous, which suggests that it doesn’t contact the butter to dodge a wreck. The hermetically sealed lid will keep the butter at room temperature.

The exquisitely cleaned serving plate will consistently keep the severe new and clean all occasions. Aside from butter, it is additionally appropriate for keeping the cheese. The moderate butter dish has a smaller structure that will consummately suit your kitchen space.

Hand wash is suggested as the butter dish isn’t dishwasher safe in addition to it is somewhat heavier in weight. However, for a tempered steel these are normal downside and ought to thus not be the major issues.


  • Fits up to two sticks of butter.
  • Attractive and highly durable stainless steel build.
  • Secure lid with a nice grip.
  • Keeps butter clean and fresh.
  • Suitable for storing cheese too.


  • It isn’t dishwasher friendly.
  • This butter dish is heavier in weight.

Buyer’s Guide:

Despite the fact that a butter dish isn’t a technical product or even something you got to put much thought of before buying but here are a few factors you should definitely consider before making your purchase.

  • Size:

Most butter dishes accessible to purchase in the US have been intended to hold between 1-2 sticks of American measured butter. The advantage of buying a bigger measured butter dish isn’t to make sure you can crush more butter into the compartment, it’s so you make less wreck. On the off chance that you buy a more profound butter dish, at that point you have less possibility of getting butter everywhere on over the lid.

  • Material:

Butter dishes regularly arrive in an assortment of materials and the most mainstream decisions are: porcelain, glass, tempered steel and plastic. On the off chance that you are picking porcelain simply know that despite the fact that it looks overly lovely, it can chip and break without any problem. One drop on the floor and your butter dish will be gone for eternity.

Glass is essentially the equivalent despite the fact that it tends to be somewhat more hard-wearing. Plastic makes a decent choice if it’s without BPA (which utilizes less synthetic substances in the assembling cycle) and break safe. Hardened steel is one of the more hard-wearing materials yet isn’t as everybody would prefer.

  • Non-Slip:

How frequently do you use butter in your family unit? In the event that you are a customary dough puncher and use butter consistently then it may merit considering a more specialized” butter dish with a non-stick base. This implies each time you utilize the dish to scratch or cut the butter, the dish won’t slide over the table.

  • Simple Grip:

It may appear to be a senseless interesting point, however on the off chance that your butter dish doesn’t contain a handle, the lid can be very hard to eliminate. The issue happens when you place an enormous stick of butter into a butter holder and the butter can soften a little and adhere to the lid.

Not exclusively would this be able to turn out to be overly untidy, yet it additionally implies that the lid can adhere to the base as well. If the dish contains a handle, at that point lifting the lid from the base is a lot simpler. We think it additionally looks prettier too on the exemplary structures.

  • Measurement Notches:

Once more, this is a helpful element for those of you who use butter to heat or cook with and furthermore individuals who are taking care of their weight and don’t have any desire to utilize a lot of butter. Estimation indents at the base of a butter dish, frequently demonstrates a teaspoon or tablespoon of butter – which makes heating excessively simple as you probably won’t need gauging scales.

Final words:

There’s a plethora of butter dishes available in the market but everyone has different needs and requirements. You got to choose what’s best for you depending on how much butter you got to store and your décor and what material you prefer. We found the OXO good grips one the best pick considering how it’s in budget and has so many pros and almost no con but you consider the buying guide and buy what’s the best for you!

Leave a Comment